Discovering History
  • Courses
    • China's Rise and Fall (spring 2018) >
      • Course Info
      • In Class
      • Assignments + Units
    • Archived Courses >
      • Living China's History >
        • Living China's History (fall 2017) >
          • Course Information
          • Course Project
          • In-Class
          • Assignments
        • Living China's History (fall 2018) >
          • In-Class >
            • The Death of Woman Wang
          • Assignments
      • China's Fall and Rise (spring 2018) >
        • Course Information
        • In-Class
        • Assignments
      • Japan's Empire and its Legacies (fall 2016) >
        • Course Information
        • Daily Review
        • Schedule >
          • JE Unit 1
          • JE Unit 2
          • JE Unit 3
          • JE Unit 4
          • JE Unit 5
          • JE Unit 6
        • Research >
          • Issues of History
          • Research Schedule >
            • Checkpoint #2: Annotated Bibliography
            • Checkpoint #3: Outline
            • Checkpoint #4: Supplemental Pages
      • Thinking about a Changing China (spring 2017) >
        • Course Information
        • In Class
        • Assignments
      • Humanities History (U.S. History) >
        • Humanities History (2017-18) >
          • Course Information
          • In-Class
          • Assignments
        • Humanities History (2016-17) >
          • Course Information
          • In Class
          • Assignments >
            • U1: The American Revolution & the Constitution
            • U2: Defining the Nation
            • U3: 19th Century Social & Cultural Transformations >
              • Cemetery Project
            • U4: A House Divided
            • U5: Industry & Empire
            • U6: Progressive Promise & Disillusion
            • U7: Global Conflicts
            • U8: Civil Rights & Human Rights
      • More Course Descriptions
    • Student Projects >
      • "Communism" (Independent Study)
      • "Issues of History" (Japan's Empire and its Legacies)
  • Skills
    • Reading >
      • Active Reading
      • Advanced Reading Strategies (Upper Mids and Seniors)
      • Outlining for Reading
      • Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Sources
      • Analyzing Primary Sources with SOAPSTone
      • Analyzing Visual Primary Sources
      • Selecting & Evaluating Secondary Sources
    • Thinking >
      • What is History?
      • Historical Thinking Chart (PDF)
      • Breaking Down History with the SPICE Factors
    • Discussing >
      • Engaging in Class Discussion
      • Evaluating Discussion
    • Researching >
      • Identifying Research Topics & Questions
      • Note Cards
    • Writing >
      • Zero Draft
      • Thesis Statements
      • Forming Counterarguments
      • Formatting Chicago-Style Papers
      • Ford Library Guide to Chicago-style Citations (PDF)
    • Tech Tips
  • Reference
    • Chinese History Tools
    • Further Reading in Asian Studies >
      • Books
      • News
      • Podcasts
    • Current Events around the World
  • About
    • About
    • Writing

#301 Market Revolution

10/29/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
Holley Knife Company, Lakeville, CT, established 1844.
Pair and share:
  • What are some ways the Market Revolution was likely to influence life in Salisbury, Connecticut?
  • Identify two examples your own life has been impacted by the consequences of the Market Revolution.

Brief overview:
  • North and South developed differently in years from 1800-1860:
    • North: urbanization, early industrialization, expansion of transport networks, and systems of credit; western farmers produced for urban centers
    • South became more committed to plantation-based agriculture, especially production of highly profitable cotton, a portion of which found its way to Northern textile factories
  • Market Revolution brought important social changes to the North:
    • Growth of cities
      • From New York in the east to Cincinnati and Chicago in the northwest.
    • New work opportunities
      • Especially important change for young women who had previously been expected to stay at home.
    • Faster modes of transportation and communication
      • Canals (built largely 1800s-20s), railways (1830s-90s), and the telegraph (from the 1830s)
    • Arrival of immigrants
      • Irish Catholics came in the largest numbers and provoked anxiety among some “nativist” Protestants
    • New waves of:
      • Religious revival: The Second Great Awakening reached its height in 1820s-30s.
      • Social reform: Labor, temperance, women’s rights, and eventually abolitionism.
      • Philosophical inquiry: Transcendentalist writers like Emerson and Thoreau (1820s-40s).

Guided research:
  • Groups:
    • Group A: Local iron ore mining
    • Group B: Local industry
    • Group C: Transportation
    • Group D: Immigration to Connecticut
    • Group E: Social movements
  • Create a joint Google Doc with your teams members to locate resources on your assigned topic from the library’s Cemetery Project LibGuide. In your Google Doc, create a table like the one below:
 
Identify the title and source of your document.
Is this a primary or secondary source? How do you know?
What can you find in this source? Why might it be useful for research?
Document #1
 
 
 
Document #2
 
  
 
Document #3
 
 
 
Document #4
 
 
 
0 Comments

#300 Salisbury 1800-1870: A Town in Transition

10/29/2016

0 Comments

 
Today, we launch our third unit, which will explore on social, economic, and cultural history of early and mid nineteenth-century America. This unit will be anchored by a week-long Cemetery Project, and therefore we will be linking much of the content to local history here in Salisbury.

As we watch this short (25-minute) documentary film, consider:
  • One point that surprised you.
  • Two questions you might have for local historian, Peter Vermilyea, who will be visiting Hotchkiss during the Consultation Period on Friday 11/4.
0 Comments

#206 & #207: Indian Removal Role Play

10/26/2016

0 Comments

 
Introduction:

Together, we have examined a range of primary and secondary sources related to how the new Constitution actually functioned in the early Republic (Marbury v. Madison and the nullification crisis). We also discussed multiple dimensions of the “democratic” visions presented by Presidents Jefferson and Jackson – including who was partially or fully excluded from those visions. Most recently, we have turned our focus more closely to the question of Indian removal, considering the competing views of President Jackson and the Cherokees.

For our unit assessment, we will join many of these threads as we discuss a key question from the perspective of September 1832 (this is after the Worcester v. Georgia decision and before the 1832 presidential election):

  • “Does the federal government have the power to forcibly remove the Cherokee Indians?”

Preparation:

Day 1:
  • Introduce simulation.
  • Provide time for research. Students are encouraged to explore the 1830 Indian Removal Act, Supreme Court decisions, treaties, and other relevant secondary sources available in your textbook and online.

Homework for day 2:
  • Assignment #207

Day 2:
  • Consult with your side for 5-8 minutes.
  • Engage in open discussion.

Detailed discussion procedure:

  • Meeting with your side (5-8 minutes). During this time, you should select one or two people to give a 1-2 minute opening statement on behalf of your group. The statement should cover the main arguments your side will make during the debate.

  • Open discussion (20-25 minutes). During the discussion the two sides will face each other on opposite sides of the table. Each side will have a chance to speak for up to 1 minute at a time, though if you may also choose to “pass” to allow the other side to renew their time.

  • Parting Shots (5-8 minutes). Each person will prepare a 30 second “parting shot” and present it at the end of the discussion. The “parting shot” should hit on the main reason why your side is correct from your character’s point of view.

Please reference this Google Doc for role assignments.
0 Comments

#205 Cherokee Perspectives on Indian Removal

10/20/2016

0 Comments

 
Background
  • Last class we discussed Indian removal from the perspective of President Andrew Jackson in his message to Congress in 1830. Today, we are going to see it from the point of view of the Indians.
  • Indian tribes and the new republic got off on the wrong foot:
    • Many Indian tribes fought on the side of the British
    • 1790s conciliatory policy: Secretary of War under Washington said, "The Indians being the prior occupants, possess the right of the soil." Jefferson at the time agreed.
    • When, however, Jefferson became president in 1800, pressure on Indians to “civilize” and adopt agriculture, and sell tracts of land emerged for first time

Cherokee perspectives on Indian removal
  • Begin by circulating around the classroom to complete the “Document Stations” chart for the following documents:
    • Document A: Tecumseh Speech, winter 1811
    • Document B: Cherokee Census Report, 1826
    • Document C: Preamble of the Cherokee Constitution, July 1827
    • Document D: The Cherokee Phoenix, 1828
    • Document E: Lewis Ross, et al, Address to the People of the United States, July 1830
  • Review information collected in charts, pausing in the third column to gather further insights.

Possible questions for discussion
  • Last class you made some predictions about the Cherokee response to Indian removal. How do your findings today match up against those predictions?
    • Which predictions have you found confirmed?
    • Which have you found challenged?
  • When we looked at the Bill of Rights, several of you indicated that the fourth and fifth amendments were especially important. Theses amendments protect against “unreasonable . . . seizure” and assure that if “private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.”
    • Are these constitutional protections relevant in this case?
  • After seeing both sides of the story, what policy approach might you have proposed to President Jackson in respect to the Cherokees and other Native Americans living in the southeast United States?
0 Comments

#204 Jackson on Indian Removal

10/17/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
Portrait of Andrew Jackson by Alexander Hay Ritchie (1860). United States Library of Congress.
Picture
"Andrew Jackson, The Great Father," cartoon (c.1830).
Preparation
  • Before class students will have read “Andrew Jackson’s Speech to Congress on Indian Removal, December 6, 1830” in the Course Reader as well as Foner, pages 301-04.

Front matter
  • CIQ reports
  • Notetaker

Word association review
  • Either take out a piece of paper or open up a Google Doc where you feel comfortable taking quick notes. Listen to the word and write down the first relevant name that comes to mind when you hear the term. Note: This is not a graded exercise.
    • Federalist Party
    • Agrarian democracy
    • Indian removal
    • Declaration of Independence
    • Nullification
    • Judicial review

Jackson on Indian removal
  • Begin by working with a partner to construct a simple chart of President Jackson’s arguments regarding Indian removal. Hint: most of the information for this chart can be found in his second paragraph of the document.
  • We will review this perspectives together as a launching point for our conversation.
Advantages of Indian removal for white Americans
Advantages of Indian removal for Indians
  • (List examples)
  • (List examples)
Further questions for discussion
  • In what ways are Jackson’s arguments in the left-hand column consistent or inconsistent with Jefferson’s vision for America’s future?
  • How do you think Indians might respond to the arguments made in the right-hand column?
  • In the second paragraph, Jackson characterizes Indians as possessing “rude institutions” and propose they should “cast off their savage habits and become an interesting, civilized, and Christian community.” What do you think he means by negative terms like “rude” or “savage” on one hand, and what do you think it would it take for Indians to become “civilized” on the other?
  • In the third paragraph, Jackson equates the westward movement of Indians with the westward movement of ancestors of white Americans. Is that a fair analogy?
  • Is Jackson’s proposition to the Indians as “benevolent” as he makes it out to be? Why or why not?
  • What alternatives might exist to Jackson’s policy? Do you think assimilating Indian populations into the U.S. would have been a viable strategy? Is it reasonable to ask them to assimilate? In what ways might a discussion of “assimilation” arise today?

Homework: #205
0 Comments

#203 Jackson and Nullification

10/13/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
Preparation
  • Before class, students will have read Foner 296-301.

Opener
  • Discuss with a partner:
    • If a state disagrees with a law made by the national government, do you think the state has a right to refuse it?
    • What if the state felt the law was unjust or oppressive?
  • We will then line up on an imaginary line that spans the room with one end representing strongly agree and the other strongly disagree. A handful of students will share reasoning for why they have chosen to stand in their particular spots.

Background
  • Andrew Jackson was a populist leader celebrated for military victories over the British at New Orleans and against Creek and Seminole Indians – all during War of 1812.
  • Won largest share (38%) of vote in 4-way election of 1824 that featured just one party, but was denied office by House of Representatives, who gave election to John Quincy Adams.
  • Won presidency in 1828 by running under banner of the “Democratic Party” with few promises, but plenty of populist rhetoric:
    • Nickname: “Old Hickory”
    • Slogan: “Vote for Andrew Jackson who can fight, not John Quincy Adams who can write.”
  • President Jackson would become embroiled in controversies over "nullification," the national bank (the Second Bank of the United States), and Indian Removal.
Picture
Election of 1824
Picture
Election of 1828
Pair questions
  • Briefly define a tariff.
  • What did the Tariff of 1828 actually do? (see Foner 299 for a refresher)
  • Why might have been controversial in some parts of the country but not in others?

Closer look at the Nullification Crisis
  • Class will be divided into three groups.
  • Your group will read, discuss, and present on one of the following passages:
    • Group A: South Carolina Exposition and Protest (1828)
    • Group B: Excerpt from Daniel Webster’s Second Reply to Hayne (January 26-27, 1830)
    • Group C: Excerpt from Andrew Jackson’s Nullification Proclamation (1832)

Group A: South Carolina Exposition and Protest (1828)
  • In article 6, the document argues that “the powers to protect manufactures, is no where expressly granted to Congress” and therefore under the tenth amendment to the Constitution should “be expressly reserved to the states.” Can you explain the argument here?
  • How do the authors understand the role of the “necessary and proper clause” (Article 1, section 8)? (To make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof.)
  • How do the authors of the document view the power of the national government to regulate commerce?
  • What action is being recommended in this document?
  • What is the strongest case you could make for defending this point of view?

Group B: Excerpt from Daniel Webster’s Second Reply to Hayne (January 26-27, 1830)
  • “Sovereignty” is often understood as the power to govern. How does Webster believe sovereignty works in the United States?
  • How might Webster’s view of sovereignty be different from advocates of “states’ rights” like Vice President John C. Calhoun?
  • How does Webster propose to deal with “unjust” laws?
  • How, for Webster, is constitutionality determined?
  • What is the strongest case you could make for defending this point of view?

Group C: Excerpt from Andrew Jackson’s Nullification Proclamation (1832)
  • Identify several of the argument against secession. Which of the arguments are most convincing to you?
  • Why does President Jackson suggest South Carolina might be guilty of “treason”? What would he do in response?
  • If individual states cannot rule on the constitutionality of legislation or actions, what entity do you think President Jackson would look to for an impartial ruling?
  • How do you think South Carolina would respond to President Jackson?
  • What is the strongest case you could make for defending this point of view?

At the beginning of next class, we will conduct a fishbowl in which one member of each group will report on the document and the rest of us will listen and then respond to the questions below:

Questions to fishbowl audience:
  • Which point of view seems most persuasive?
  • Was the nullification of the tariffs an appropriate response from those who disagreed with them?
  • What can/should people do if they disagree with a law?
  • Was President Jackson’s response appropriate?
  • What might have happened if South Carolina had not repealed the nullification ordinance?

Homework: #204
0 Comments

#202 “The Very Essence of Judicial Duty”: Marbury v. Madison

10/10/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
Supreme Court justices attend the 2016 State of the Union address.
Preparation
  • Before class, students will have read Marbury v. Madison (1803) (pared down to only sections explaining judicial review) and Foner, page 237, “Judicial Review.”

Opener
  • How might the 2016 election impact the Supreme Court? Why (or why not) does this matter to you?

Review homework
  • With a partner, review your answers to the questions to consider for homework. Together we will review the first question:
    • "What did Chief Justice John Marshall say was the chief purpose of written constitutions in Marbury v. Madison (1803)?"

New Jersey v. T.L.O.
  • Review case information (external link) provided by the Chicago-Kent College of Law.
  • Working individually or with a partner (whichever you prefer), use “Charting Supreme Court Cases” (Google Doc) to complete the top row of the chart pertaining to New Jersey v. T.L.O.
  • Briefly discuss together.

Justice Thomas on judicial review
  • The case above is a more recent example of how the Supreme Court conducts judicial review.
  • Together, we will watch Justice Clarence Thomas discuss judicial review (external link, 3:17)

Marbury v. Madison
  • Complete the second row of the chart using information from Marbury v. Madison (as a primary source document) and Foner (as a secondary source).
  • Briefly discuss together.

Justice Ginsburg on the impact of Marbury v. Madison
  • Together, we will watch Justice Ginsburg discuss the impact of Marbury v. Madison (external link, 1:27).

Final thoughts
  • Concluding comments (as time allows).

Homework: #203.
0 Comments

#201 "Empire of Liberty"

10/10/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
Detail from "George Town and the Federal City, or City of Washington" by George Beck (artist) and T. Cartwright (engraver), 1801. The George Washington University Museum
Pair and share
  • Address focus questions from last night’s homework:
    • ​What was the nature of Jefferson’s “democratic vision”? Why – and for whom – was the American nation being constructed?
    • Identify concrete steps taken by Jefferson to promote his vision.

Early Republic Scavenger Hunt
  • You will be working with a partner on this exercise.
  • To begin, make a of this document and placing it in the Shared Folders for both partners (in the Google Docs menu, select File → Make a Copy).
  • There are no restrictions on how you search the information for this activity. However, please keep a complete list of the tools and sources you use.
  • When you have completed this activity, indicate you have done so by saying “bazinga!”

Thinking like a historian
  • Once you have finished, take a few minutes with a partner to identify at least two potential narratives (stories) you see to organize some or all of the information you have collected.

Homework: #202
0 Comments

#200 “What, then, Is the American?”

10/7/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
North Carolina Emigrants: Poor White Folk, by James Henry Beard, 1845. Cincinnati Art Museum.
Constitution essay due.

Introduction to unit 2
  • Focus is on how political machinery of the Constitution wrestled with the demands of the growing nation, especially in relation to westward expansion and the Native American population.
  • Shorter unit than #1, and will end with a simulation rather than an essay.

Opening question
  • Who, under this new Constitution, counts as an “American”?

Primary source-based reading

(1) Crèvecoeur, “What, then, Is the American?”
  • Read a brief selection from Crèvecoeur, “What, then, Is the American?” (Google Doc)
  • Consider the following discussion questions:
    • What characteristics of American life does Crèvecoeur emphasize as being different from European society?
    • What aspects of society, and which parts of the people living in the United States, are left out of his description?

(2) Citizenship in the new republic
  • In-class reading: Naturalization Act of 1790 (link here to Google Doc; also in Course Reader)
  • Consider the following discussion questions:
    • Who was eligible and not eligible for citizenship under the Naturalization Act?
    • Why would the United States, known as the “asylum for mankind,” restrict opportunity for naturalization?

Homework: #201
0 Comments

#115 Peer Review

10/6/2016

0 Comments

 
Only students who have completed the full text of their essay and included appropriate citations may proceed to this level. Students who need additional time may continue drafting in the library.

Introduction
  • Sharing comments with your classmates is a useful way to improve your writing. This is a valuable skill that can help you at university and in your future career and creative pursuits.
  • Some quick advice on best practices:
    • A note to reviewers: Your main purpose is to help the writer produce a better paper. No paper is beyond criticism. At the same time, there is always a kind way to offer any criticism, and you should choose this way. Everyone who cares about their writing also feels deeply insecure about it. 
    • A note to writers: The natural first reaction to any criticism is defensiveness and sometimes anger at the commentator. It is better not to express this. Use the feedback constructively and assume it was meant in kindness. At the same time, write something that you want to take responsibility for, since in the end it is your name at the top of the page.
  • This exercise is worth 5 points. It will be evaluated based on evidence of you having completed the survey and providing meaningful spoken feedback to your peer.

Process
  1. Share your essay using Google Docs as "view only."
  2. Read your partner's essay once through without commenting.
  3. Based on your partner's essay, complete the Google Forms survey (shared by teacher). Most questions on this survey are multiple choice. For questions that are open response, 1-2 sentences should be sufficient for each.
  4. When you are done, press "submit." A copy of the survey will appear in your inbox. Please forward a copy of this to your partner.
  5. Once you and your partner have both completed the survey, take turns using the survey to discuss one another's papers with a focus on how you can both improve your writing.
0 Comments
<<Previous
    U7 Assignments
    U8 Assignements
    Research Project

    Archives

    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016

    Categories

    All
    Civil War
    Cultural History
    Current Events
    Founding Documents
    Local History
    Race
    Rights
    Social History
    Supreme Court
    Writing

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Courses
    • China's Rise and Fall (spring 2018) >
      • Course Info
      • In Class
      • Assignments + Units
    • Archived Courses >
      • Living China's History >
        • Living China's History (fall 2017) >
          • Course Information
          • Course Project
          • In-Class
          • Assignments
        • Living China's History (fall 2018) >
          • In-Class >
            • The Death of Woman Wang
          • Assignments
      • China's Fall and Rise (spring 2018) >
        • Course Information
        • In-Class
        • Assignments
      • Japan's Empire and its Legacies (fall 2016) >
        • Course Information
        • Daily Review
        • Schedule >
          • JE Unit 1
          • JE Unit 2
          • JE Unit 3
          • JE Unit 4
          • JE Unit 5
          • JE Unit 6
        • Research >
          • Issues of History
          • Research Schedule >
            • Checkpoint #2: Annotated Bibliography
            • Checkpoint #3: Outline
            • Checkpoint #4: Supplemental Pages
      • Thinking about a Changing China (spring 2017) >
        • Course Information
        • In Class
        • Assignments
      • Humanities History (U.S. History) >
        • Humanities History (2017-18) >
          • Course Information
          • In-Class
          • Assignments
        • Humanities History (2016-17) >
          • Course Information
          • In Class
          • Assignments >
            • U1: The American Revolution & the Constitution
            • U2: Defining the Nation
            • U3: 19th Century Social & Cultural Transformations >
              • Cemetery Project
            • U4: A House Divided
            • U5: Industry & Empire
            • U6: Progressive Promise & Disillusion
            • U7: Global Conflicts
            • U8: Civil Rights & Human Rights
      • More Course Descriptions
    • Student Projects >
      • "Communism" (Independent Study)
      • "Issues of History" (Japan's Empire and its Legacies)
  • Skills
    • Reading >
      • Active Reading
      • Advanced Reading Strategies (Upper Mids and Seniors)
      • Outlining for Reading
      • Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Sources
      • Analyzing Primary Sources with SOAPSTone
      • Analyzing Visual Primary Sources
      • Selecting & Evaluating Secondary Sources
    • Thinking >
      • What is History?
      • Historical Thinking Chart (PDF)
      • Breaking Down History with the SPICE Factors
    • Discussing >
      • Engaging in Class Discussion
      • Evaluating Discussion
    • Researching >
      • Identifying Research Topics & Questions
      • Note Cards
    • Writing >
      • Zero Draft
      • Thesis Statements
      • Forming Counterarguments
      • Formatting Chicago-Style Papers
      • Ford Library Guide to Chicago-style Citations (PDF)
    • Tech Tips
  • Reference
    • Chinese History Tools
    • Further Reading in Asian Studies >
      • Books
      • News
      • Podcasts
    • Current Events around the World
  • About
    • About
    • Writing